
← All articles
Team connection
How to help new joiners feel they belong
Most onboarding tells new people how things work but leaves belonging to chance. What theatre knows about welcoming someone, and what a team can do.

Joost
Co-founder & CEO
·
7 min read
By the end of their first week in a new job, most people have been handed a laptop, a stack of logins, a deck about the company values and a calendar full of introductory calls. They know where the meeting rooms are and which tool the team uses for what. Then, at lunch on Friday, somebody mentions a project from three years ago, the whole table laughs, and the new person smiles along a beat later than everyone else. A week later they know a great deal. What they often do not yet know is whether they are wanted.
In the sessions we run at Uncommon Club, people who have known each other for years often stand next to one or two who arrived last month. You can usually spot the newest person in the first few minutes, not because they look lost but because they are watching so carefully. They are reading the room for rules nobody has said out loud. That watching takes a surprising amount of energy, and most onboarding does very little to reduce it.
Being informed is not the same as being included
The organisational psychologist Talya Bauer describes onboarding on four levels: compliance (the rules and policies), clarification (what the job involves and what good looks like), culture (how things are really done here) and connection (the relationships a new person needs in order to do well). Most organisations handle the first two reasonably well, because they fit neatly into a checklist. Connection is the one most often left to chance, or to whoever happens to sit nearby.
That matters more than it sounds. In an influential paper, the psychologists Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary argued that the need to belong is a fundamental human motivation, not a pleasant extra. A new person who has not yet found their place spends real effort working it out: second-guessing small decisions, holding back an opinion until they understand how opinions are received here, wondering whether the silence after their last message meant anything. All of that is energy that is not available for the job they were hired to do.
Every team runs on rules nobody wrote down
Every team has a hidden layer. Who you can interrupt and who you cannot. How direct feedback is allowed to be. Whether ‘urgent’ means today or this week. Which channel is for real questions and which is for show. Long-standing members stopped noticing these rules years ago, and new people notice little else.
Theatre has a nice answer to this. When an actor joins a production that is already running, the company often holds what is called a put-in rehearsal: the cast runs the show with the newcomer so they can find their place before an audience arrives. What I like about it is the direction of effort. The ensemble adjusts to the new person, rather than leaving the new person to work out the ensemble alone.
Teams can borrow the spirit of that cheaply. Ask two or three people to write down what they wish someone had told them in their first month, and turn it into a short, honest and slightly informal guide. Then ask every new joiner to add one thing once they have been around for a quarter. It costs an hour and saves weeks of quiet guessing, and it tells the newcomer something important: we know there is a hidden layer, and we are happy to show it to you.

Belonging is built by peers, not by the process
HR and the line manager set the scene, but belonging is mostly built by colleagues, in small moments. When you introduce someone, introduce the person rather than the CV: why they were hired and, with their permission, something about them beyond the job title. Give them a buddy who is not their manager, someone to ask the questions that feel too small or too awkward for a boss. If the team works hybrid, make sure their office days are the days the team is actually there. An empty office is a lonely place to start.
The most useful gift is often an early, real contribution. A small task that helps a colleague does more for belonging than another week of shadowing, because it lets the new person be useful rather than merely welcomed. The same goes for their fresh eyes. Asking ‘What seems strange to you about how we work?’ turns their newness into something of value instead of a gap to close, and it tends to surface things the rest of the team stopped seeing long ago.
Old stories keep new people at the edge
Shared history is the quiet barrier in most teams. The in-jokes, the tales from the launch that nearly went wrong, the nicknames for old projects: this is how a group recognises itself, and it is lovely, but every one of those stories is a door the newcomer cannot walk through yet. The answer is not to retire the old stories. It is to make some new ones that everybody starts at the same point.
This is where an activity that is new to everyone can do something an introduction round cannot. In our Storytelling sessions, people shape a short true story from their own lives and tell it in small circles, and I often see colleagues of many years learn something about each other at exactly the same moment as the person who joined last week. In Trust Games, the exercises start light and ask a little more each time, so a newer person can build working trust with a whole group in an afternoon rather than one conversation at a time. Nobody has home advantage, and the story the team later tells about that afternoon belongs to all of them.

Ask better questions than ‘how is it going?’
Managers often ask new people how they are getting on and accept ‘fine’ as the answer. Better questions open better conversations, and they work best when they change over time. After the first week, ask what has surprised them so far, and who they have met that they would like to know better. After the first month, ask whether there is anything they have been unsure they are allowed to do, and when they have felt most part of the team, and when least.
After three months, the questions can turn around. What would they tell the next person who joins? What do they see that the rest of the team has stopped noticing? The answers to that last round are worth feeding straight back into the guide to the unwritten rules, which is how it stays honest.
Month two matters more than day one
Most of the attention a new joiner gets arrives in the first week, which is also when they need it least. The welcome lunch is easy to organise and everyone is curious. The harder stretch comes in the second and third month, when the novelty has worn off, the real questions begin and the calendar has quietly filled up with ordinary work. That is when a buddy who checks in, or a lead who remembers to ask a better question, makes the most difference.
It gets harder still when a team grows quickly and several people join at once. A divide can form between ‘the originals’ and ‘the new ones’, with different references and very different amounts of shared history. The longer it goes unaddressed, the more it hardens, so it is worth marking those moments deliberately, with something the whole team does together for the first time.
Belonging rarely arrives in a single moment you can schedule. It shows up in small signs: the first time a new colleague makes a joke the room gets straight away, or pushes back in a meeting without first checking whether they are allowed to. If you lead a team, the most useful thing you can do is make those moments a little more likely, and then notice when they happen.
Onboarding
Belonging
New Joiners

About the author
Joost
Co-founder & CEO
Joost leads Uncommon Club’s brand, proposition and commercial direction, shaping how the collective’s artistic practice becomes something companies understand, trust and bring into their teams. He co-founded the club after a cycling trip through Patagonia.
Keep reading




