Why experiential learning sticks and slides fade

← All articles

Experiential learning

Why experiential learning sticks and slides fade

Being told gives a team a fact; doing something together gives it a memory. Why that difference matters, and how to make an afternoon of practice reach Monday.

Oktay

Oktay

Co-founder & COO

·

·

7 min read

Picture the first morning of a team offsite. The leadership team walks everyone through a carefully built deck: next year’s strategy, the priorities, the values that should guide how people work together. It is clear and well designed, and people nod along. In the afternoon, an artist runs a short impro exercise in which the group has to tell a story one word at a time. It falls apart within a minute. One person keeps trying to steer, another keeps adding ‘suddenly’, and the whole thing collapses into laughter.

Ask people a few weeks later what they remember from those two days, and I can usually tell you which part they will mention. A lot of my time at Uncommon Club is spent in the room on the day and in the conversations afterwards, and the pattern repeats itself. Almost nobody quotes slide fourteen. Plenty of people still talk about the story that would not stay on track, and what it showed them about who in the team likes to steer. That is not because the deck was bad. It is because the two halves of the day asked people to learn in very different ways.

Being told gives you a fact, doing gives you a memory

When someone tells you something, you walk away with a fact. When you do something, you walk away with a memory that has a body attached to it: a particular room, a particular moment of getting it wrong, the particular feeling of a group working something out together. Facts are fragile under ordinary working pressure. Hermann Ebbinghaus showed in the 1880s how quickly newly learnt material slips away when it is not used again, and anyone who has tried to recall a training day a month later knows the feeling.

Memories with feeling and movement in them tend to last longer. Because they are tied to more than words, there are more ways back into them. A gesture, a phrase someone used, the way the light fell in the room can bring the whole moment back, and with it the point it made. A lesson you lived through simply has more hooks than a lesson you were shown.

The idea is old, and still underused

None of this is new. In Experience and Education (1938), the philosopher John Dewey argued that education should grow out of real experience rather than rote learning and instruction from above. Building on Dewey and others, David Kolb described experiential learning in 1984 as a cycle: a concrete experience, reflection on what happened, a conclusion drawn from it, and then trying again differently. Most good teachers, coaches and theatre directors work this way without ever drawing the diagram.

So why do so many workplaces still default to telling? Partly because telling is easy to organise. A deck can reach a hundred people in an hour, and attendance is simple to count. Experience asks for more: time, space, a skilled person to hold the room, and the patience to let a group find something out rather than be handed it. With my operations hat on, I understand the pull of the deck very well. But it is efficient at passing on information and far less efficient at changing what people do.

Getting it wrong on purpose is often the lesson

One of the things artists do well is design small, safe failures. In a Clowning session, Martin Ciesielski sets up little harmless flops on purpose and teaches people to let the room laugh with them instead of freezing up. In impro theatre, a well-known exercise asks pairs to plan an event by answering every suggestion with ‘yes, but’, and then to plan it again with ‘yes, and’. The first round grinds to a halt. The second takes off. Nobody needs to be told which one felt better, or which one sounds more like their Monday meeting.

There is good reason this works. Psychologists have long described what they call the generation effect: people tend to remember things better when they produce them themselves than when they simply read them. A conclusion a group reaches on its own, having felt the difference in the room, belongs to the group in a way a slide never quite does. Nobody has to be persuaded of something they found out for themselves.

A participant laughs in the middle of a scene during Impro Theatre

A shared memory is remembered together

There is a second reason experience lasts, and it is social. When a team goes through something together, the memory does not live in one head but between people. Months later, someone in a meeting says ‘let’s not yes-but this’, and the whole group remembers the exercise at once: not only the words, but the feeling of the plan grinding to a halt and the laugh that followed.

That shared shorthand is one of the most valuable things a session leaves behind, and slides rarely create it. A phrase from a deck is rarely used in a meeting without a touch of irony. A phrase from a moment the team lived through together can turn a discussion in a few seconds, because everyone in the room knows what it points to.

Reflection turns an event into learning

An exercise without reflection is just an event. It might be fun, even useful, but without a moment where the group connects what happened to how it works, the afternoon stays sealed off from Monday morning. This is why we build reflection into every session rather than treating it as spare time at the end, and why the cool-down matters as much as the peak.

The artist’s job in that closing conversation is not to explain what the exercise meant. It is to ask the questions that let the group explain it to itself. One of the closing prompts in our deck of conversation cards simply asks: what surprised you about today? It sounds almost too simple, and it works because the answer has to come from the person holding the card. My co-founder Jonel has written in more detail about how to debrief an experiential learning session.

Purple Uncommon Club conversation cards with prompts such as Reflect and Imagine on a dark floor

Safety comes from sequence

The last piece is safety, specifically the kind that lets a team get something visibly wrong in front of each other without anyone needing to protect their status afterwards. It does not happen by accident, and it cannot simply be announced. Telling a group ‘this is a safe space’ at the start changes very little. What changes things is the order in which you ask people to do things.

Good sessions start with something low-stakes and slightly silly that everyone does at once, so nobody is being watched. They move to pairs and small groups before anything happens in front of the whole room. They only ask for real exposure once the group has laughed together and seen that getting it wrong is survivable, and even then taking part is an invitation: anyone can step back and observe. This is the main reason we work with experienced, hand-picked artists who know how to build a room step by step. Get the sequence right and a single afternoon can change how a team talks to each other long after it ends. Get it wrong and the same activity becomes one more thing that happened to people, rather than something they did together.

Let slides inform and experience change

None of this means throwing out the deck. Slides are good at what they are for: sharing information, setting out a plan, putting numbers in front of people. The trouble starts when we ask them to do the other job as well, changing how people behave with each other, and are then surprised when Monday looks like every other Monday.

If you are planning a team day, a practical rule is to pair each important message with something people can do. If the strategy depends on departments listening to each other, give people twenty minutes in which they can only succeed by listening to each other, before the slide about collaboration goes up. Afterwards, pick one phrase the group came up with itself and use it in the next meeting, and the one after that. Experience gives a team something to remember. Coming back to it, a little and often, is what makes it stick.

Experiential Learning

Group Psychology

Oktay

About the author

Oktay

Co-founder & COO

Oktay runs the operational backbone of Uncommon Club, from how artists are booked and briefed to how a session comes together on the day. He co-founded the club in Berlin in 2025, alongside Joost and Jonel, to make spontaneous moments happen reliably.

Get in touch

Let’s talk through your programme.

Joost, co-founder of Uncommon Club
Oktay, co-founder of Uncommon Club

Tell us about your team, your occasion and what you want your people to walk away with. We’ll suggest the most impactful sessions and the artists who could lead them, tailored to your brief.

Want to send us an email? hello@uncommon.club

Get in touch

Let’s talk through your programme.

Joost, co-founder of Uncommon Club
Oktay, co-founder of Uncommon Club

Tell us about your team, your occasion and what you want your people to walk away with. We’ll suggest the most impactful sessions and the artists who could lead them, tailored to your brief.

Want to send us an email? hello@uncommon.club

Get in touch

Let’s talk through your programme.

Joost, co-founder of Uncommon Club
Oktay, co-founder of Uncommon Club

Tell us about your team, your occasion and what you want your people to walk away with. We’ll suggest the most impactful sessions and the artists who could lead them, tailored to your brief.

Want to send us an email? hello@uncommon.club