Why teams warm up before they open up

← All articles

Team connection

Why teams warm up before they open up

Every group starts out polite. Why teams need to warm up before honest conversation is possible, what performers know about it, and how to try it on Monday.

Joost

Joost

Co-founder & CEO

·

·

6 min read

Picture the first morning of a team offsite. Twenty people sit in a horseshoe, laptops closed, and the lead opens with the question the whole day is meant to be about: ‘So, what is really going on in this team?’ There is a pause. Then someone offers a careful, sensible answer about communication between departments. Somebody else agrees. The flipchart fills up with points that are true and safe, and by lunch the room has had a thoughtful conversation that will change very little.

Nothing went wrong there, exactly. The question was a good one. It was simply asked too early, of a group that had not yet done anything together that day except arrive. A lot of what we do at Uncommon Club begins in exactly that state, and watching artists handle it has taught me that groups warm up before they open up. The warm-up is not a polite delay before the real work. It is part of the real work.

Every group starts out polite

Group psychology has described this for a long time. In Bruce Tuckman’s well-known model, teams move through forming, storming, norming and performing. Forming is the polite, slightly guarded phase in which everyone is reading the room and nobody wants to be the first to say something unpopular. Tuckman was describing groups that are new to each other, but I see a version of it whenever a team gathers in an unfamiliar setting, even among people who have worked side by side for years. A new room, a new kind of activity and a different mix of people put most of us back into forming for a while.

Anyone who leads groups feels it within minutes. People stand near the walls. Coats stay on. Laughter comes quickly and is a little too polite. Nobody is being difficult. They are doing what people sensibly do in an uncertain situation: holding back until they understand what is safe.

Skip the warm-up and you get polished honesty

The mistake I see most often, in ourselves as much as in the teams we work with, is trying to go straight to the honest, high-trust conversation without doing anything to move the group out of that first stage. It rarely works. A team that has not warmed up together will usually offer a polished, safe version of honesty, the kind that sounds reflective in the room and changes nothing afterwards.

Amy Edmondson, whose research brought psychological safety into everyday management language, describes it as a shared belief within a team that it is safe to take interpersonal risks. The important word there is shared. It is not enough for the lead to announce that this is a safe space. Each person has to see, with their own eyes, that someone else took a small risk and the group responded well. Until that has happened a few times, people protect themselves, and they are right to.

Performers never go on cold

No professional performer walks on stage cold. Actors, singers and dancers all warm up, and the reason is only partly physical. A theatre warm-up loosens the body and the voice, but it also does something for the ensemble: it brings everyone’s attention into the same room and onto each other before anything that matters happens.

Watch an impro company before a show and you will often see a circle game such as Zip Zap Zop, in which a clap and a word are passed quickly around the group. It looks silly. What it does is serious. Everyone has to listen, everyone makes a sound, mistakes happen within seconds and get laughed at, and by the end the group is moving at one tempo. That is a compact version of what a team needs before a difficult conversation: everyone has spoken, everyone has failed a little, and nothing bad happened.

Participants gather in a loose circle around a player on a dark stage during Impro Theatre

What a warm-up actually changes

A good warm-up does several things at once, and none of them is obvious from the outside. It moves people’s attention out of their inboxes and into the room. It gets every voice heard early, which matters, because the first time you speak in a group is always the hardest and it gets easier after that. And it creates small, harmless failures in public, which are the raw material of psychological safety. When someone forgets the word in a game, the room laughs and they laugh too, the whole group has just watched a risk being taken and met kindly.

This is the argument for starting a day with something that looks, on paper, unrelated to its purpose: a game, a voice exercise, a piece of physical theatre. It is not an icebreaker in the throwaway sense. It is a deliberate and fairly quick way of moving a group through the guarded early stage, so that the harder conversation later has somewhere real to land. In an Impro Theatre session, for example, the first half hour is almost entirely this kind of play, and the honest reflections tend to arrive afterwards without anyone having to ask for them.

Warm up in the right order

Order matters as much as content. Every session we run follows an arc of warm-up, peak and cool-down, and the warm-up always begins with the whole group doing something together before anyone does anything alone. Moving around the room as a group is easier than standing in the middle of a circle. Making a sound with everyone is easier than making one by yourself. Only once the group has done a few of these things together does an artist ask anything of an individual.

Participation also has to stay invitational. In our sessions anyone can step back and watch, and the warm-up is designed so that watching is a real way of taking part rather than a quiet exclusion. People warm up at different speeds. Someone who spends the first ten minutes observing often joins in fully later, precisely because nobody pushed.

A warm-up for Monday’s meeting

None of this needs an artist or an offsite to be useful. If you have a difficult conversation coming up, do not put it first on the agenda at nine in the morning. Put it after something the group has done together, even if that something is small. Start with a round in which everyone answers an easy question in a sentence, so that every voice has been in the room before the hard part begins. If the group has been sitting for an hour, stand up for two minutes. If people are joining remotely, ask them to have their cameras on for the first five minutes and to say one thing, however small.

And if the room still gives you the polished version, treat that as information rather than failure. It usually means the group has not warmed up yet, not that it has nothing to say. Most teams open up eventually. The ones that do it sooner have usually found a way to play together first. There is more on how this connects to everyday trust in my piece on psychological safety.

Group Psychology

Team Dynamics

Joost

About the author

Joost

Co-founder & CEO

Joost leads Uncommon Club’s brand, proposition and commercial direction, shaping how the collective’s artistic practice becomes something companies understand, trust and bring into their teams. He co-founded the club after a cycling trip through Patagonia.

Get in touch

Let’s talk through your programme.

Joost, co-founder of Uncommon Club
Oktay, co-founder of Uncommon Club

Tell us about your team, your occasion and what you want your people to walk away with. We’ll suggest the most impactful sessions and the artists who could lead them, tailored to your brief.

Want to send us an email? hello@uncommon.club

Get in touch

Let’s talk through your programme.

Joost, co-founder of Uncommon Club
Oktay, co-founder of Uncommon Club

Tell us about your team, your occasion and what you want your people to walk away with. We’ll suggest the most impactful sessions and the artists who could lead them, tailored to your brief.

Want to send us an email? hello@uncommon.club

Get in touch

Let’s talk through your programme.

Joost, co-founder of Uncommon Club
Oktay, co-founder of Uncommon Club

Tell us about your team, your occasion and what you want your people to walk away with. We’ll suggest the most impactful sessions and the artists who could lead them, tailored to your brief.

Want to send us an email? hello@uncommon.club